CTA Name/dba Commodity Rate Type Commodity Cost, If Variable Index/Metric Used Additional Fees Contract Length Early Termination Fee? Amount of Early Termination Fee Other
AAA Natural Gas  Variable  NGI PGE Citygate Plus Negotiated Adde $0.05/Day, unless negotiated  12, 24 or 36 Months with Yearly Renewals Unless Negotiated  No     
AAA Natural Gas  Variable Inside FERC PGE Citygate Plus Negotiated Adder $0.05/Day, unless negotiated  12, 24 or 36 Months with Yearly Renewals Unless Negotiated  No     
AAA Natural Gas  Variable Nymex LDS Plus Negotiated Adder $0.05/Day, unless negotiated  12, 24 or 36 Months with Yearly Renewals Unless Negotiated  No     
AAA Natural Gas  Fixed Negotiated Rate  $0.05/Day, unless negotiated  12, 24 or 36 Months with Yearly Renewals Unless Negotiated  Yes  Dependent on the Length of the Contract that Remains    
AAA Natural Gas
Flat Negotiated Rate 
  12 Months  No     
Ambit California, LLC  Fixed $0.119/therm   12 months    
Ambit California, LLC  Variable $1.19/Therms

Variable rate products are subject to change without notice, may thus vary from customer to customer, and may change due to current and predicted weather patterns, retail competition, fluctuations in energy supply and demand, industry regulations, pricing strategies, and costs to serve customers, among many factors.
  Month-to-Month     Variable is not currently being offered for acquisition or renewals. Customers can still roll to a variable product if they fail to renew. 
Bolt Energy Services Variable $1.49/Day *for first Month

Subsequent Months, the rate may vary based upon changes to energy supply and demand, real-time wholesale energy costs, industry regulations, and costs to serve customers, among other business factors.  Current effective variable rate for August 2023 is $1.49/Day.
$0.49/Day Month to Month No
Commercial Energy of Montana, Inc. Variable Citygate Index Settle Price Plus Negotiated Management Fee   Negotiated Term Yes Calculated based on termination date
Commercial Energy does not market directly to Residential customers. Residential customers are only served as part of aggregations with commercial customers.
Commercial Energy of Montana, Inc. Fixed Negotiated   Negotiated Yes Calculated based on termination date Commercial Energy does not market directly to Residential customers. Residential customers are only served as part of aggregations with Commercial customers.
Just Energy Solutions Inc.  Fixed  Negotiated Rate    12, 24, 36, 48, 60 Months  Yes  $150.00   
Just Energy Solutions Inc. Variable
$9.99/Month
Month to Month  Yes  $150.00  
National Gas & Electric  Flat  $1.49/Day  
12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00     
National Gas & Electric  Flat  $1.49/Day      12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Flat  $1.49/Day     12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Fixed  $1.49/Day      12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.49/Day      12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.49/Day      12 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.49/Day      12 Months, then Month to Month Yes  $125.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.99/Day      6 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $2.99/Day      6 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $50.00   
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.49/Day    Month to Month  No    
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $1.99/Day    Month to Month  No     
National Gas & Electric  Variable  $2.99/Day     Month to Month  No     
North Star Gas Company LLC, dba YEP Energy  Flat  No Charge $60/Month  12 or 24 Months, then Month to Month  Yes  $100.00   
Peak 6 Power & Gas Flat $40.00/Month   12 months, then month to month No  
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $0.92/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 Months   Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California, Inc. Flat $1.07/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 24 months Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining
SFE Energy California, Inc. Flat $1.07/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 36 months Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat $1.07/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 60 months Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining
SFE Energy California, Inc. Flat $1.13/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 24 months Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat $1.13/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 36 months Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat $1.19/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 36 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $1.19/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 60 months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining    
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $1.23/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month 24 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California, Inc. Flat  $1.23/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month 36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $1.23/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  60 months  Yes $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat   $1.25/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  24 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat   $1.25/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $1.25/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month 60 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $1.29/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  24 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $1.29/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  36 Months   Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $1.29/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  60 Months   Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $1.32/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  24 Months   Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $1.39/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $1.39/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  60 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $37.73/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $43.53/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.  
$6.98/Month   48 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $43.53/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $43.53/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  60 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $45.49/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  48 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $45.94/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $45.94/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month 60 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $46.26/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California Inc.   Flat  $48.36/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California, Inc.  Flat  $48.83/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year.
$6.98/Month 24 months Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
SFE Energy California, Inc.   Flat $48.83/Day

This rate applies to residential customers with natural gas consumption that does not exceed 600 therms per year. 
$6.98/Month  36 months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
Smart One Energy LLC  Variable  SmartOne does not base its variable rate on a specific index/metric, but rather has the discretion to change the rate based on changing gas market conditions as needed.  With very few California customers, SmartOne has largely not needed to change its rates since it first set them for its limited number of customers.   None  12 Month, then Month to Month   No    
Spark Energy Gas LLC  Fixed   $0.749/Therm consumption of 50 therms $4.95/Month  12 Month, then Month to Month  No     
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      24 Months   Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      36 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining  
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      60 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      60 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      36 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      60 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      36 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat     60 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC Flat      36 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      60 Months  Yes   $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC Flat      60 Months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
StateWise Energy California LLC  Flat      24 Months  Yes  $7.50/Whole or Partial Month Remaining   
Symmetry Energy Solutions  Fixed  Negotiated Rate    12 Month, then Month to Month   No    Legacy Product, Not Actively Market/Offered
Symmetry Energy Solutions   Variable  PGE CG Index Plus
$0.199/therm 
  12 Months, then Month to Month  No    Legacy Product, Not Actively Market/Offered 
Symmetry Energy Solutions   Variable  Weighted Average Cost of Gas    Month to Month  No      Legacy Product, Not Actively Market/Offered
Vista Energy Marketing L.P. Flat  $1.190/Day   $0.16/Day  12 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $0.15/Day     13 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $0.99/Day    14 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.19/Day     15 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.29/Day     16 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.39/Day     17 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.45/Day      18 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.49/Day     19 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $1.99/Day     20 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $2.49/Day    21 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $2.99/Day    22 Months, then Month to Month  No     
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $3.49/Day    23 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Vista Energy Marketing L.P.  Flat  $3.99/Day    24 Months, then Month to Month  No      
Wave Energy  Variable  The rate is fixed for the first month then is variable based upon customer annualized historical usage for twelve months. During such initial twelve month term, customers with annualized customer usage of 0-200 therms will pay $45 in the first month; 201-600 therms will pay $65; 601+ will pay $1.19 per therm. After the initial twelve month term, customers costs will fluctuate on a month to month basis based on energy supply and demand, industry regulations, pricing strategies, and costs to serve customers, among many factors.  $14.99/Month  12 Months  No    
XOOM Energy California, LLC Fixed $0.609/Therms $2.99 per month 12 months, then month to month Yes $70.00 Charitable Plan - 5% of customer's commodity spend is donated to PetSmart Charities
XOOM Energy California, LLC Variable Introductory rate of $0.749/therm for first 3 bills, followed by effective variable rate in subsequent months. $2.99 per month 12 months, then month to month No   Airline Rewards Plan -Qualified customers earn 5,000 miles/points for each natural gas account they enroll, after the account has been active for 2 months; and an on-going reward of 2 miles/points for every $1 charged on the supply portion of their monthly natural gas bill.
XOOM Energy California, LLC Variable Introductory rate of $0.739/therm for first 2 bills, followed by effective variable rate in subsequent months. $2.99 per month 12 months, then month to month No   Monthly Rewards - Qualified customers earn $100 each month in XOOM Energy Rewards
XOOM Energy California, LLC Fixed $0.639/therm $2.99 per month 12 months, then month to month Yes $70.00
XOOM Energy California, LLC Fixed $0.649/therm $2.99 per month 24 month, then month to month Yes  
XOOM Energy California, LLC Variable Introductory rate of $0.679/therm for first 2 bills, followed by effective variable rate in subsequent months. $6.99 per month 12 months, then month to month No   Carbon Offset Plan - XOOM purchases carbon offsets equivalent to 100% of the amount of carbon emissions associated with a customer's natural gas usage while on the plan.
XOOM Energy California, LLC Fixed $0.569/therm $6.99 per month 12 months, then month to month Yes $70.00 Carbon Offset Plan - XOOM purchases carbon offsets equivalent to 100% of the amount of carbon emissions associated with a customer's natural gas usage while on the plan
XOOM Energy California, LLC Fixed $0.579/therm $6.99 per month 24 month, then month to month Yes $137.00 Carbon Offset Plan - XOOM purchases carbon offsets equivalent to 100% of the amount of carbon emissions associated with a customer's natural gas usage while on the plan